| 5/13/2025 | 6:15 PM | Caledonia | 3 | Albion SC | 2 | Caledonia-Mumford High School F1 |
| 5/20/2025 | 6:15 PM | Brockport Blizzard White | 2 | Caledonia | 4 | Sweden Town Park #5A |
| 5/22/2025 | 6:15 PM | Livonia Storm | 4 | Caledonia | 3 | Willow Creek #3 |
| 5/27/2025 | 6:15 PM | Caledonia | 4 | Cobras FC G16/17 | 2 | Caledonia-Mumford High School F1 |
| 6/03/2025 | 6:15 PM | Caledonia | 2 | Livonia Storm | 0 | Caledonia-Mumford High School F1 |
| 6/12/2025 | 6:15 PM | Caledonia | 0 | Brockport Blizzard White | 0 | Caledonia-Mumford High School F1 |
| 6/17/2025 | 6:15 PM | Hilton Heat | 6 | Caledonia | 0 | Parma Town Park #7 |
| 6/24/2025 | 6:15 PM | Caledonia | 0 | Canandaigua Attack | 8 | Caledonia-Mumford High School F1 |
| 7/01/2025 | 6:15 PM | Caledonia | 0 | Hilton Heat | 1 | Caledonia-Mumford High School F1 |
| 7/15/2025 | 6:00 PM | Cobras FC G16/17 | 4 | Caledonia | 0 | Grace & Truth Park F2S |
| 7/17/2025 | 7:30 PM | Canandaigua Attack | 1 | Caledonia | 3 | Finger Lakes Community College #4 |
| 7/21/2025 | 6:15 PM | Albion SC | 0 | Caledonia | 2 | Bullard Park #1
|