The Board shall evaluate coaches throughout the regular season and shall vote to determine All-Star Coaches for each division at the end of the regular season.  The focus of NHLL is on player development and emphasis will be placed on all coaches to adhere to the Mission Statement.  Coach performance may be assessed by win/loss record, coach surveys, player surveys, parent surveys, umpire surveys, or other criteria deemed appropriate by the Board.  At their discretion, the Managers Committee may create a point system for coach evaluation.  In the event that a point system is created, the terms of the system will be provided to all head and assistant coaches.

The head coach must be able to be present throughout all levels of the Little League tournament season.

During the selection process, a coach may elect to vacate his opportunity to be the head coach.

The coaches committee will present a recommendation to the board for the all-star coaches before the all-star selection. The local board shall then vote to accept or reject the recommended all-star coaches.

A maximum of three adults per division will be permitted to serve as all-star coaches.  The all-star head coach has the ultimate decision right for the selection of the 2nd and 3rd all-star coaches.  Consideration should be given to the other division head coaches in addition to assistant coaches.  Availability should also be considered as the individuals on the affidavit are the only coaches allowed on the field before and during the game.

Board approved all-star coaches are responsible for the selection of all-stars players.  Players should be selected based upon their playing ability, eligibility, availability.  Coaches may rely upon input from the Board, umpires, other coaches, and other players, as recommended by Little League Tournament Rules and Guidelines.  Teams must be 12-14 players.  Refer to the Little League Rulebook concerning mandatory play (Tournament Rule 9) 

Before all-star selection, coaches should consult with the league president or player agent about player eligibility per Little League rules.  For eligible players, coaches should inquire with parents about player availability. Once player eligibility and availability is established for the entire division, all-stars shall be selected.  Announcement of all-stars shall occur the same day as selections and be announced from the league before communicated by coaches.

Any misconduct and/or unsportsmanlike conduct may be taken into consideration for all-star players eligibility.

At its discretion, the Board may remove a player from an all-star team for misconduct and/or unsportsmanlike conduct, including conduct by parents.